Skip to main content

Tier List

Our Silent Whispers tier list ranks all cards based on affection boost, story value, versatility, pull efficiency, and scaling. Rankings are updated regularly based on community data, banner releases, and event performance trends.

Character Route Rankings

S TierMust-have cards — the highest affection bonuses, best story content, and essential for True Endings
CharacterPersonalityPower
VincentComposed, mysterious, secretly tenderShadow
RyanWarm, loyal, steadfastly devotedLight
ZacharyBrilliant, sharp, secretly caringIce
A TierStrong cards — excellent affection boosts and story content for the right character route
CharacterPersonalityPower
IvanMagnetic, enigmatic, dangerously charmingDreams
LiamGentle, artistic, deeply sincereFlame

Card Rankings

S Card TierMust-have cards — the highest affection bonuses, best story content, and essential for True Endings
CardRarityCharacter
Moonlit ShadowLegendaryvincent
Sunlit EmbraceLegendaryryan
Frost CrownLegendaryzachary
A Card TierStrong cards — excellent affection boosts and story content for the right character route
CardRarityCharacter
DreamweaverLegendaryivan
Blaze HeartLegendaryliam
Whisper at DuskEpicvincent
Golden LaughterEpicryan
B Card TierSolid cards — good for mid-game and specific event strategies
CardRarityCharacter
Ice EtiquetteEpiczachary
Canvas SkyEpicivan
Ember DefianceEpicliam
Shadow VeilRarevincent
C Card TierNiche cards — useful in limited situations or as upgrade material
CardRarityCharacter
Radiant SmileRareryan
Crystal GazeRarezachary
Pastel SketchRareivan
Flame BadgeRareliam

How We Rank Cards

Ranking Criteria

  • Romance Value: How much affection the card provides and how it enhances relationship progression with its featured character.
  • Versatility: How useful the card is across different routes, events, and game content
  • Affection Boost: How much affection the card provides with its featured character
  • Card Power: Overall card effectiveness — damage output, healing strength, and utility value in events and routes.
  • Deck Synergy: How well the card synergizes with other cards in optimal deck builds.

Community Sources

  • Rankings are based on community testing and affection farming data
  • Card value varies with character route, event type, and team composition
  • Tier placements may shift with new banner releases and game updates
  • Always check the official Discord for the latest meta discussion official Discord

Frequently Asked Questions

How often is the tier list updated?+
We update the tier list after every new banner release and major game update. Minor adjustments are made weekly based on community feedback and event performance data.
Why are character SSR cards always S tier?+
Character SSR cards earn S tier due to their unmatched affection bonuses, premium story content, and exclusive CG illustrations. They provide the most value per pull and are essential for reaching True Endings.
Are lower-tier cards useless?+
Not at all. Lower-tier cards serve as valuable upgrade material and some R cards have surprisingly useful affection bonuses for specific characters. Tier rankings reflect overall value, not absolute usefulness.
Does the meta change often?+
The meta shifts with each new banner and event. VVANNA STUDIO typically introduces new cards every 2-4 weeks. Join our Discord to get notified about tier list changes as they happen.

Card Rankings